Books Received
Primate-Science / PrimateLit
CLADISTICS: A PRACTICAL PRIMER ON CD-ROM
CLADISTICS: A PRACTICAL PRIMER ON CD-ROM
By Peter Skelton and Andrew Smith
Accompanying booklet by Neale Monks
Cambridge University Press, 2002
FROM THE BACK COVER
Cladistics and phylogenetic reconstruction are subjects which biology
students find quite difficult to grasp when taught from conventional
textbooks. This CD provides students with a complete self-study
introductory course in phylogenetic reconstruction using cladistic
analysis. The CD is fully interactive and includes animated sequences,
questions at the end of each section, and practical exercises. It is
the first exclusively pedagogical CD-ROM devoted to this topic. By the
end of the course students should have a basic understanding of
cladistics and be ready to reconstruct phylogenetic relationships from
morphological and molecular data
The CD-ROM is accompanied by a short textbook. The book is meant to be
used in conjunction with the CD-ROM but can act as a stand-alone aid
to learning when the reader is away from the computer.
Peter Skelton is based in the Department of Earth sciences in The open
University, Milton Keynes, UK.
Andrew Smith is a palaeontologist in The Natural History Museum,
London and is a Fellow of the Royal Society.
Neale Monks is a science writer and biology teacher based in London.
SYSTEM REQUIREMENTS: PC with Pentium 200 MHz processor or Mac PowerPC
and above. Windows 9S or Mac OS 7.6 and above. CD-ROM drive, 32
megabytes of RAM.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Preface, vii
About the CD-ROM and the booklet, ix
Instructions for installing and running the CD-ROM, x
1. FIRST PRINCIPLES
1.1 Reconstructing evolutionary history from observed differences, 1
1.2 Parsimony and tree reconstruction, 16
2. CHARACTERS AND HOMOLOGY
2.1 Homology and homoplasy, 26
2.2 Homology in molecular data, 29
2.3 Character definition, 33
2.4 Weighting, 39
3. CLADOGRAMS AND TREES
3.1 Rooting procedures and character polarity, 40
3.2 Cladograms, phylograms and phylogenetic trees, 45
3.3 Monophyly, paraphyly and polyphyly, 48
3.4 Consensus trees, 50
4. FIT AND ROBUSTNESS
4.1 Measuring goodness of fit, 55
4.2 Tests of robustness, 64
5. PRACTICAL
5.1 Phylogenetic analysis of eight species of sea-urchins, 66
5.2 Cladistic analysis of morphological characters, 67
5.3 Cladistic analysis of molecular characters, 75
5.4 Comparison of results and conclusions, 78
Appendix: Cladistics software, 79
PREFACE
The last few decades have seen a revolution in the reconstruction of
evolutionary relationships. Eclectic models based on ad hoc arguments,
and hence liable to subjectivity, have been replaced by a consistent
methodology - cladistics - that is open to objective evaluation. Two
technological innovations have helped to foment this revolution.
First, computing, especially the rise of personal computers, has made
easy the previously unthinkable task of sifting through myriads of
alternative trees of shared ancestry, as required by the method.
Second, molecular sequencing of genes and their products has provided
a rich new source of evidence that is also amenable to cladistic
analysis, in addition to conventional morphological data. Where these
two discrete sources of data yield the same phylogenetic conclusion, a
high degree of confidence can be placed on it. Thus what before was
virtually a priestly art practiced by taxonomic specialists has become
a robust science.
Consequently, discussion of cladistics forms a necessary component of
any modern course on evolution. However, many students have
difficulties getting to grips with the strict logic of the method, not
to mention its somewhat daunting technical vocabulary. Accordingly,
the Evolution Course Team at the Open University decided in 1998 that
treatment of the topic could especially benefit from the lively and
colourful medium of an interactive CD-ROM, and thus the present
project was born. A proposal for the structure and content of the
CD-ROM was commissioned from Andrew Smith at the Natural History
Museum, and this was realised in detail by Peter Skelton at the Open
University, working with a technical design team from BBC Factual &
Learning (MK). Co-publication was agreed with Cambridge University
Press, who commissioned the present
booklet from Neale Monks - an inspired choice - to accompany the
CDROM. We, the authors of the latter, are indeed most grateful to
Neale for the elegant but down-to-earth guidance notes and backup
information that he has provided here for users of the CD-ROM.
Peter Skelton
Open University, Milton Keynes
Andrew Smith
Natural History Museum, London
WHERE TO ORDER
Cambridge University Press
110 Midland Avenue
Port Chester, NY 10573-4930
phone: (914) 937-9600
toll free: 800-872-7423
Fax: (914) 937-4712
http://us.cambridge.org
ISBN: 0-521-52341-9 $55.00
Posted Date: 5/8/2003